
WhatsApp messages, text conversations and social media communications can play an important part in police investigations involving allegations of rape and sexual assault.
In cases where the parties previously knew each other, the messages exchanged before or after the alleged incident may provide useful evidence about the circumstances, the relationship and particular matters that are disputed.
However, digital communications can be misunderstood when viewed in isolation. A message which appears helpful to the defence may have a very different meaning when considered alongside the surrounding conversation or other evidence.
At McMillans Solicitors, we specialise in defending people accused of sexual offences. In this article, we explain how WhatsApp messages may feature in an investigation, what the police and CPS are expected to consider, and why it is important to preserve relevant communications from the outset.
Can WhatsApp messages be used as evidence in a rape case?
Yes. WhatsApp messages and other electronic communications may be used as evidence in criminal proceedings, provided they satisfy the applicable legal requirements.
Messages may be relevant to:
- The nature of a relationship between the individuals involved.
- Arrangements made before an alleged incident.
- Particular conversations or events relevant to the allegation.
- The chronology of communications following the incident.
- Disputed statements, explanations or allegations.
- The credibility or reliability of particular accounts.
- Specific factual issues arising from the defence case.
Whether any particular message is relevant or admissible depends on its content, context and the issues in dispute.
Electronic messages should not be regarded as automatically supporting either the prosecution or the defence.
Can friendly messages sent after an alleged rape prove that the allegation is false?
No. Friendly or affectionate messages sent after an alleged sexual offence do not, by themselves, prove that an allegation is false.
People may react to traumatic or distressing experiences in different ways, and there is no single response that must follow a sexual assault.
Nevertheless, communications after an alleged incident may be relevant to particular disputed facts. Their significance must be assessed carefully and without assumptions about how someone should behave.
For example, a message may contain a factual statement about where someone was, what was said or what happened at a particular time. Such evidence may need to be examined alongside witness accounts, CCTV or other available material.
The important question is not whether a message seems unusual or surprising, but whether it helps resolve a genuine issue in the case.
Do messages showing previous consent prove consent on another occasion?
No. This is an important distinction.
Under section 74 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003, consent requires agreement by choice, with the freedom and capacity to make that choice.
Previous consensual sexual activity, flirtatious communications or the exchange of intimate messages does not automatically establish consent to a later sexual act.
Consent must be considered in relation to the particular activity and circumstances in question. In rape cases, there may also be an issue concerning the defendant’s reasonable belief in consent.
This does not mean that communications can never be relevant. Their possible evidential significance must be considered in the context of the precise allegation and the applicable law.
What if the police only look at selected messages?
This can be an important issue in cases involving lengthy electronic conversations.
A small selection of messages may not convey the full meaning of an exchange. Earlier or later communications may explain a reference, clarify the timing of events or provide context for a disputed statement.
The CPS guidance on communications evidence recognises the importance of electronic communications in criminal investigations, particularly where the complainant and suspect previously had a personal relationship.
It may therefore be necessary to consider whether additional relevant communications should be obtained or examined.
However, this does not justify an indiscriminate examination of somebody’s entire private communications. Investigators must identify reasonable lines of enquiry and act proportionately.
Can the defence ask the police to examine the complainant’s phone?
Potentially, but there is no automatic right to have a complainant’s mobile phone seized, downloaded or searched.
Investigators must pursue reasonable lines of enquiry, including those which point away from a suspect as well as towards them. The enquiry must have a proper factual foundation and be proportionate.
The CPS’s Disclosure Manual guidance on digital material addresses these principles.
Where a suspect or their solicitor identifies specific relevant communications, it may be appropriate to ask the police to investigate them.
The stronger approach is usually to explain precisely what material is believed to exist, why it is relevant and how it may affect a disputed issue.
A general assertion that the complainant’s phone might contain something helpful is unlikely to be sufficient.
Should I provide screenshots of my WhatsApp messages to the police?
Before providing messages to the police, it is sensible to obtain advice from a specialist sexual offences solicitor.
Screenshots may be useful, but they can omit surrounding messages and may not contain all the information needed to establish their authenticity or context.
The original device and the complete relevant conversation may be important. In some circumstances, a forensic examination or properly preserved export may be more useful than isolated screenshots.
Do not delete, edit or selectively alter messages in an attempt to improve your position. That may seriously damage your credibility and could give rise to further legal difficulties.
Similarly, do not assume that a message which appears embarrassing or unhelpful should be removed. Your solicitor needs an accurate understanding of the relevant evidence, including material which might support the prosecution.
What if messages have been deleted?
The deletion of a message does not necessarily mean that it can never be recovered.
Depending on the circumstances, relevant material may still exist on another participant’s device, in an available backup or in other lawfully obtainable records.
However, recovery is not guaranteed. WhatsApp’s encryption, device settings, backup arrangements and the passage of time can all affect what material remains available.
A solicitor may be able to advise whether there is a realistic and proportionate forensic enquiry to pursue.
What about Instagram, Snapchat and other social media messages?
The same broad evidential principles apply to communications through Instagram, Snapchat, Facebook Messenger, dating applications and other platforms.
Each platform has different features concerning message storage, deletion and access to historical information.
Relevant material should be preserved promptly and lawfully. Where a platform allows temporary or disappearing messages, delay may make it more difficult to establish exactly what was communicated.
Can evidence of a complainant’s previous sexual history be used?
There are significant legal restrictions on evidence and questioning about a complainant’s previous sexual behaviour.
Section 41 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999 restricts the circumstances in which such evidence may be introduced or questions asked, subject to statutory exceptions and the permission of the court.
Consequently, the existence of messages referring to previous sexual activity does not mean that they can automatically be used at trial.
The defence must consider the precise content, the issue to which the material relates and whether any necessary application to the court is justified.
Why early legal advice matters
One of the practical difficulties in sexual offence investigations is that potentially relevant digital material may become harder to retrieve as time passes.
It is therefore important to identify and preserve relevant evidence at the earliest appropriate opportunity.
In a case where an allegation is disputed, a solicitor may consider:
- What relevant conversations remain available.
- Whether messages have been preserved in their proper context.
- Whether any communications support or contradict material aspects of the allegation.
- Whether there are relevant independent witnesses or other records.
- Whether further reasonable enquiries should be requested.
- Whether the evidence supports a basis for making representations before a charging decision.
For more information about preparing a defence, see our guidance for those falsely accused of a sexual offence.
Frequently asked questions
Can WhatsApp messages prove that I am innocent?
They may provide important evidence, but their significance depends on what they establish and how they relate to the allegation. No single message should be assessed without considering the relevant context.
Will the police automatically examine all messages between us?
Not necessarily. Digital examinations should be directed towards reasonable and proportionate lines of enquiry. The scope depends on the particular investigation.
What if the complainant has deleted our conversations?
Copies may remain elsewhere, but recovery cannot be assumed. Your solicitor can consider whether further lawful enquiries are appropriate.
Should I contact the complainant to ask for copies of messages?
No direct contact should be attempted without obtaining legal advice. Contact may breach bail conditions or other restrictions and could be interpreted as interference with a witness.
Can messages be considered before I am charged?
Yes. Relevant digital evidence may be considered during the investigation and may, in suitable circumstances, form part of representations made before the charging decision.
Specialist sexual offence solicitors at McMillans Solicitors
At McMillans Solicitors, we specialise in defending allegations of rape, sexual assault and other sexual offences.
We understand the importance of carefully examining the evidence, including communications that may support the defence or raise questions requiring further investigation.
If you are being investigated for rape or sexual assault, early specialist advice can help you understand your position and take appropriate steps to preserve relevant evidence.
Call 01992 566730 for a confidential discussion or contact McMillans Solicitors online.