News & Blog

The latest updates from McMillans Solicitors...

Can Pre-Charge Representations Prevent a Rape or Sexual Assault Charge?

Legal documents relating to pre-charge representations in a sexual offence investigation.

If you are under investigation for rape or sexual assault, you do not necessarily have to wait for the police and Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) to decide whether to charge you before taking positive steps in your defence.

In appropriate circumstances, a specialist criminal defence solicitor can make written representations to the police or CPS before a charging decision is made. These are commonly known as pre-charge representations.

The purpose is to ensure that important evidence, legal arguments and relevant information are considered before any decision to prosecute.

At McMillans Solicitors, we specialise in defending allegations of sexual offences. We recognise that the period between a police interview and a charging decision can be one of the most stressful stages of an investigation, particularly where someone strongly denies the allegation.

What are pre-charge representations?

Pre-charge representations are submissions made on behalf of a suspect before the police or CPS decide whether criminal proceedings should begin.

They may explain why the available evidence does not justify a prosecution, identify material that supports the defence, challenge an important aspect of the allegation or suggest further reasonable lines of enquiry.

In rape and serious sexual offence cases, the police will commonly seek charging advice from the CPS. A solicitor may ask the investigating officer to consider representations and, where appropriate, ensure that relevant material is brought to the prosecutor’s attention.

There is no automatic entitlement to prevent a charging decision while representations are prepared, or to require the CPS to accept them. Their timing, content and potential value must be considered carefully.

How does the CPS decide whether to charge someone?

Under the Code for Crown Prosecutors, the usual charging decision involves the Full Code Test, which has two stages.

1. The evidential stage

The prosecutor must consider whether the evidence provides a realistic prospect of conviction. This requires an objective assessment of the available material, including any defence or explanation advanced by the suspect.

A case that cannot satisfy the evidential stage must not proceed under the Full Code Test, however serious the allegation may be.

2. The public interest stage

Where there is sufficient evidence, the prosecutor must consider whether a prosecution is required in the public interest.

Sexual offences are serious allegations and the public interest will ordinarily favour prosecution where the evidential test is satisfied. However, the decision must still be made on the particular facts.

In certain limited circumstances, a separate Threshold Test permits a charging decision before the Full Code Test is satisfied. That is not the ordinary approach to a lengthy investigation in which the suspect remains at liberty.

When might pre-charge representations be useful?

Not every sexual offence investigation is suitable for pre-charge representations. Their value often depends on whether there is something meaningful that can be put before the decision-maker.

Examples might include:

  • Important digital evidence: messages, emails or social media communications which are relevant to the allegations.
  • Independent witnesses: individuals who can give evidence about relevant events, conversations or the circumstances surrounding an allegation.
  • CCTV or location evidence: material capable of supporting or challenging a particular account of what happened.
  • Inconsistencies requiring examination: significant discrepancies between accounts or other evidence which may affect the reliability of the prosecution case.
  • A legal issue: an argument that the available evidence does not establish a necessary element of the alleged offence.
  • Outstanding enquiries: identifiable lines of investigation which could materially affect the charging decision.

The mere fact that someone denies an allegation will rarely be sufficient. A persuasive representation should identify specific issues and explain their evidential or legal significance.

Can pre-charge representations lead to no further action?

Yes, in an appropriate case. Representations may help the police or CPS recognise that the evidence is insufficient, that additional enquiries are required, or that a particular charge is not supported.

However, pre-charge representations do not guarantee that the police will take no further action.

A prosecutor may consider the representations and nevertheless conclude that the evidence justifies a charge. Alternatively, additional enquiries may strengthen rather than weaken the prosecution case.

The objective should be to achieve a fair and properly informed decision, not simply to submit a lengthy document containing every argument that might eventually be advanced at trial.

Should representations be made before or after the police interview?

Usually, the first priority is obtaining appropriate legal advice about the police interview itself.

What a suspect says during interview can be significant. Depending on the evidence disclosed and the circumstances, a solicitor may advise answering questions, providing a prepared statement or exercising the right to silence. These decisions require individual advice, including consideration of the possibility of adverse inferences.

Following the interview, there may be an opportunity to review the available information, obtain relevant defence evidence and decide whether written representations would be appropriate.

In some cases further enquiries should be pursued before representations are submitted. In others, an early intervention may be justified because there is an identifiable evidential problem which ought to be addressed immediately.

For further information, see our page on specialist police station advice and assistance.

What about allegations arising from a previous relationship?

In some investigations the complainant and suspect have known each other for months or years. There may be a considerable quantity of communications, together with a complicated history which needs to be understood.

In such cases, the defence may identify messages or other evidence that is relevant to a disputed issue. But a previous relationship, consensual sexual activity on other occasions or friendly messages do not automatically establish consent to the incident under investigation.

The legal assessment must focus on the alleged offence and the relevant circumstances. For some cases that will involve a detailed examination of consent and the defendant’s alleged belief in consent. In others, the issue may be whether the alleged incident occurred at all.

Our website provides further information about rape allegations and sexual assault investigations.

Should I contact the complainant to obtain evidence?

Do not contact the complainant or potential witnesses to discuss the allegation without first obtaining legal advice.

Contact may breach police bail conditions or other restrictions. Even where no express condition applies, attempts to discuss an allegation or persuade someone to change their account may be interpreted as interference with a witness.

Relevant evidence should be identified and preserved through lawful means, with appropriate advice about how it should be obtained and presented.

What are the risks of making pre-charge representations?

Representations can be helpful, but they should never be treated as a formality.

They may reveal aspects of the proposed defence, draw attention to evidence that requires further investigation or commit the suspect to an account before all the material has been obtained.

A solicitor must balance the possible benefit of influencing the charging decision against the risk of revealing information prematurely.

Equally, there are cases where remaining passive until a charging decision is made may result in an opportunity being missed to identify relevant evidence or raise a significant weakness.

Good pre-charge work involves judgment about whether, when and what to submit.

Can a solicitor obtain the full police file before making representations?

Not ordinarily. There is no general right to receive the complete prosecution case or all unused material simply because a person is under investigation.

The police may provide information during the investigation, particularly for interview purposes, but the extent of disclosure at this stage will often be limited.

This makes it especially important to distinguish what is established by evidence, what the client has reported and what remains unknown.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to admit an offence to make pre-charge representations?

No. Representations can be made on behalf of someone who completely denies the allegation. They may challenge whether there is sufficient evidence to justify a charge.

Will the CPS consider my solicitor’s representations?

Relevant defence information may be put before the police and, where appropriate, the CPS. However, the process is not a formal appeal hearing and there is no automatic guarantee of a particular response or outcome.

Can representations be made while I am released under investigation?

Potentially. A solicitor can consider representations while an investigation is ongoing, including where the suspect is released under investigation.

What if I have already been charged?

The focus then changes to reviewing the prosecution evidence, disclosure, case preparation and the available options within the court process. There may still be opportunities to make representations to the prosecution, but these are no longer pre-charge representations.

Specialist advice from McMillans Solicitors

At McMillans Solicitors, we concentrate on defending individuals investigated or prosecuted for offences of a sexual nature.

Where a client is facing a serious allegation, we believe it is important to examine the evidence and the available options at the earliest appropriate stage. This includes considering whether there is a proper basis for pre-charge representations.

We offer privately funded specialist legal representation and can advise on the most appropriate next steps in your particular circumstances.

If you are under investigation for rape, sexual assault or another sexual offence, call 01992 566730 for a confidential discussion or contact McMillans Solicitors online.


Scroll to Top